Skip to main content

The Hidden Value: Contractor vs. Mentor in the Age of Twin Tsunamis



Let me share something I've learned over the years about the difference between bringing in a contractor versus engaging with a mentor. This distinction becomes super important when we think about the silver and skill tsunamis hitting our industry.


Understanding the Core Difference

Think about it like going to the gym. A contractor is like having someone do your workout for you - sure, the exercise gets done, but you don't get any stronger. A mentor is like having a personal trainer who shows you proper form, pushes you when needed, and helps you understand why each exercise matters.

The Contractor Approach

When organizations bring in contractors, they typically focus on:

  • Getting specific tasks completed
  • Meeting immediate project deadlines
  • Filling temporary skill gaps
  • Delivering predefined outcomes

Here's the thing though - when that contractor leaves, they take their knowledge with them. The organization hasn't grown stronger. They haven't built any muscle, if you will.

The Mentor Difference

At UnleashU, we've seen that mentorship takes a completely different approach:

  • Knowledge transfer becomes the primary goal
  • Skills are developed through guided practice
  • Understanding the 'why' behind solutions
  • Building internal capability and confidence
  • Creating conditions for growth through productive struggle

Addressing the Twin Tsunamis

The silver tsunami (loss of experienced workers) and skill tsunami (rapid technological change) create a perfect storm in our industry. Here's why mentorship matters more than ever:

  1. Knowledge Preservation
    • Mentors document processes and decisions
    • They create reusable frameworks
    • They build institutional knowledge
  2. Skill Development
    • Hands-on learning with guidance
    • Safe spaces to make mistakes
    • Real-world problem solving experience

The Cost Consideration

Now, I know what you're thinking - mentors often cost more upfront than contractors. But here's the thing: when you look at the total cost of ownership, mentorship is an investment that keeps paying returns.

Think about it this way - if you hire a contractor ten times to solve the same type of problem, you've paid ten times for the same solution. With a mentor, you pay once to build the internal capability to solve that problem forever.

Making the Transition

If you're looking to move from a contractor model to a mentorship model, here's where to start:

  1. Identify key knowledge areas that need development
  2. Look for partners who emphasize teaching, not just doing
  3. Create safe spaces for learning and experimentation
  4. Measure success by knowledge transfer, not just task completion

The UnleashU Approach

At UnleashU, we're obsessed with creating conditions where others can unleash their potential. That means:

  • Setting up controlled environments for practice
  • Collecting data on learning outcomes
  • Adjusting approaches based on individual needs
  • Building confidence through guided experience

Remember - process, not outcome. A mentor helps you build the process that leads to consistent outcomes long after they're gone.

Moving Forward

The next time you're facing a technical challenge, ask yourself: Do you want someone to solve it for you, or do you want to build the capability to solve it yourself? The answer to that question should guide your choice between a contractor and a mentor.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Overlooked Challenge of Knowledge Debt in IT

Information technology departments often focus conversations around “technology debt” on the need to regularly replace and update hardware and software infrastructure. However, there is another crucially important, yet often overlooked, component of technology debt – knowledge debt. Knowledge debt refers to the gap between individual knowledge and organizational knowledge about how technology systems are configured, deployed, and managed within a specific environment. When new technologies are implemented, typically individual contributors take responsibility for deployment based on their personal expertise. Over time though, those individuals’ undocumented understandings and insights into the how technology works becomes "knowledge debt" if they are not effectively converted into organizational knowledge. This knowledge debt poses huge risks as refresh projects and personnel changes occur. If individual knowledge has not been mapped to organizational systems and processes,...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Curse of Skill Obsolescence

As IT leaders, we are constantly facing the challenge of keeping our teams' skills relevant in a field that evolves at lightning speed. With new technologies entering the marketplace daily, it's easy for hard-won knowledge to suddenly become obsolete. This skill obsolescence puts us in a difficult position - should we retrain existing staff or attempt to bring in new talent who may be more familiar with the latest trends? Neither option is easy or guaranteed to succeed. I believe the root of this problem lies not with the pace of technological change, but with how we approach learning and development. Too often, our training focuses narrowly on specific tasks and tools rather than broader concepts. For example, we teach employees how to configure and maintain legacy telephony systems without giving them a deeper grounding in networks, protocols, audio encoding, and the like. So when a new technology like VoIP comes along, they lack the context and adaptability to smoothly tran...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Gift of Empowerment: An Investment That Never Stops Giving

You know how it feels to get that perfect gift - the one that made you smile when you first opened it and every time you use it? Now, imagine a gift that actually grows more valuable over time. That's what happens when you give someone the gift of empowerment through knowledge. Sure, a lifetime supply of anything sounds terrific (who wouldn't want endless coffee or chocolate?), but eventually, even "lifetime" supplies run out. Subscriptions expire. Memberships lapse. But when you teach someone how to understand and solve problems on their own? That's the gift that keeps on multiplying. Here's the thing about empowerment - it's not just about showing someone how to do something. It's about helping them understand the whole picture. Think of it like this: instead of just teaching someone the steps of a recipe, you're helping them understand why certain ingredients work together, how flavors complement each other and what makes a dish truly special. O...
Post a Comment
Read more